Q4 Fraud Impact Report - Email & Ticket InvestigationRisk & Fraud
All trialsGemini 3.5 FlashTrial 10
Trial reward
Gemini 3.5 FlashFail
Trial 10 — 1st of 10 by reward score. This model averages 18.2% across 10 trials on this task.
- 2/11Checks passed
- 4Turns
- 1Tool calls
- 1.2mTime
Missed 9 of 11 checks — found_fraudulent_activity_thread, found_unauthorized_charges_thread and q4_fraud_impact_channel_in_database and 6 more.
checks (11)
found_fraudulent_activity_threadLLMFail
Failure mode Wrong answer
Reason
assertion_failedfound_unauthorized_charges_threadLLMFail
Reason
assertion_failedq4_fraud_impact_channel_in_databaseFail
Reason
assertion_failedslack_lists_ticket_11533Fail
Reason
assertion_failedslack_lists_ticket_20644Fail
Reason
assertion_failed- avoided_deletionsLLMPass
- avoided_ticket_status_changesLLMPass
checked_conversations_ticket_11533LLMFail
Reason
assertion_failedchecked_conversations_ticket_20644LLMFail
Reason
assertion_failedfound_fraud_ticket_11533LLMFail
Reason
assertion_failedfound_fraud_ticket_20644LLMFail
Reason
assertion_failed
User prompt → 4 turns · 1 tool call → final response
1list_threads1
Tool execution only — no assistant text
list_threadsq=fraud, userId=me
Arguments
q=fraud, userId=me
Output
success: true error_message: null tools_list: null tool_result: success: true result: threads: - id: 69d40faf-863d-573d-9c22-88d7cbc3c4de snippet: Hello [ORGANIZATION_0001] team! I did use a typo in my email invite to my wife which seems to have resulted in PERSON_65175_NAME being caught up in all these. Please do remove her email! On [DATE_142… historyId: 6824 messages: - id: e7f07192-8a12-52b8-97a8-9b7185418edd threadId: 69d40faf-863d-573d-9c22-88d7cbc3c4de labelIds: [] snippet: Hello [ORGANIZATION_0001] team! I did use a typo in my email invite to my wife which seems to have resulted in PERSON_65175_NAME being caught up in all these. Please do remove her email! On [DATE_142… historyId: 6822 internalDate: 1636137999000 sizeEstimate: 3605… 3,022 more characters of output in the raw trajectory.
2\n ]\n}"}}
\n ]\n}"}}
3{ "email_scope": { "threads_found": 1, "messages_found": 1, "main_senders": [ "PERSON_59273_NAME" ], "main_responders":…
{
"email_scope": {
"threads_found": 1,
"messages_found": 1,
"main_senders": [
"PERSON_59273_NAME"
],
"main_responders": [
"PERSON_60399_NAME"
],
"highest_risk_thread": {
"subject": "Re: Welcome to the Money Date Magazine!",
"parties": [
"PERSON_59273_NAME",
"PERSON_60399_NAME",
"PERSON_59422_NAME"
],
"description": "A user reported PERSON_59422_NAME for fraud, stating they are using their information to enroll in multiple financial programs."
}
}
}4{"email_scope": {"threads_found": 1, "messages_found": 1, "main_senders": ["PERSON_59273_NAME"], "main_responders": ["PE…
{"email_scope": {"threads_found": 1, "messages_found": 1, "main_senders": ["PERSON_59273_NAME"], "main_responders": ["PERSON_60399_NAME"], "highest_risk_thread": {"subject": "Re: Welcome to the Money Date Magazine!", "parties": ["PERSON_59273_NAME", "PERSON_60399_NAME", "PERSON_59422_NAME"], "description": "A user reported PERSON_59422_NAME for fraud, stating they are using their information to enroll in multiple financial programs."}}}
1 failure mode across 9 verifier failures
1Wrong answerView on Failure Modes ↗Answer1 failure
Failure evidence · per affected verifier